The Desert-Island Mascaras Our Editors Can’t Live Without

Quite frankly, if there were a deserted island for every mascara that people claim they would bring with them should they ever end up stranded, you’d have to start searching for more ocean. (Jury’s still out on whether long, fluttery eyelashes could actually be considered an effective SOS plan.)
Still, in a sea of formulas that each promise to lengthen, curl, or bulk yours up, choosing the right mascara for you can feel like a treasure hunt. So we asked POPSUGAR beauty editors to share the tubes they’d swim to shore with – ahoy.